Consumer Blog
Timeshares vs. fractional ownership
When considering investing in a vacation property, you should weigh the pros and cons of both timeshares and a popular new option called fractional ownership. What many people think of as a timeshare is actually fractional ownership.
The two differ in that with timeshares, you pay to stay in the home you share with other people and do not have any ownership of the property. With fractional ownership you actually own a percentage-along with a number of other people-of a home or condominium, including the cost of the home, taxes and maintenance.
According to a recent Bankrate.com article, an increasing number of Americans are choosing fractional ownership over timeshares because of the perceived advantages of owning a percentage of a vacation home. For instance with fractional ownership, you have more control of where you'd like to vacation. When you choose a timeshare, you may not have the choice of your perfect destination. Another benefit to fractional ownership is the possibility of earning equity with the appreciation of the property. Whether you are thinking about fractional owner in a Tuscan villa for a quarter of the year, or in a timeshare in Branson for a week, both options come with risks.
You may have read previous blog entries pertaining to fraud that occurs in the timeshare industry. Complaints of scams received by our office include timeshare companies that try to sell properties that don't exist. Or, they might lead you to believe that the property is in a more desirable location than it is; for instance, the company may promote the location is "seaside" or "oceanfront" when it is really miles from the beach.
There are disadvantages and risks to fractional ownership too. As with any ownership, you are in charge of maintenance, insurance, etc. With an unstable housing market, you may not be able to sell your part of the property. Finally, there are currently very few lenders who are willing to finance a fractional ownership. Bottom line: When considering either timesharing or fractional ownership, you should have a "buyer beware" mentality. And look at this as a luxury expense, rather than an investment. It is wise to investigate as much as possible and have an attorney review any contracts before you make a decision.
Technorati Tags: fractional ownership, timeshares, travel scams, vacation property, moagoconsumer, consumer protection
Posted by on August 20, 2007 8:45 am :: Comments (3) :: Permalink
3 Responses to "Timeshares vs. fractional ownership"
says:
August 22, 2007 2:22 pm
While this is a good attempt to clarify the situation, there are some factual errors in this article. First, timeshares in the US are primarily deeded, which means the owner actually owns that unit of property for the week they have bought, along with the taxes and associated maintenance fees. Second, when buying a specific deeded timeshare week, you have absolute control over where and when you will have your vacation, as opposed to floating weeks or the use of a points-based system. I agree that research and doing the proper homework is essential for any purchase, and timeshares should be seen as purchasing a vacation expereince rather than an investment. However, the real issue is that this discussion involves two different types of potential customers. The fractional customer is someone with much more money to invest, typically hundreds of thousands of dollars to buy into a multi-million dollar home or villa in an area they couldn't typically afford, for an extended period of time. The timeshare customer is someone looking for more of a resort holiday with a few thousand dollars to spend at a specific resort, or trade for another resort unit. You're really comparing apples to oranges with this question.
says:
November 16, 2007 10:46 pm
I have found the timeshares has booming in some area, it depends on what kind of timeshare it is.
says:
December 21, 2007 6:00 pm
i have observed on your website that you have taken action against a company doing business in your state "festiva".
i own several timeshare weeks at a caribbean resort that they manage. i believe that they are trying to defraud my family out of tens of thousands of dollars through what i believe to be bogus asssessments and imtimidation and also by treats of voiding our leases.
I reside in NJ and need assistance in persuing this matter leagaly. any help would be deeply appreciated. thank you
